This topic is a kind of survey to figure out if the ELL community would like to have a single, uniform Community Wiki question to keep all of the resources in a single place.

Since we are in the Beta, I guess we need a month so that a common consensus was found.

I would ask diamond moderators to mark it for a better promotion.

Relevant links

share
    
@kiamlaluno Would you please comment on your edit? I don't quite follow how it improved the question. –  bytebuster Feb 20 '13 at 15:59
1  
It has been pointed out before: Questions on meta should not be written as pools. Since it is a discussion, it is not fair to suggest what the users should say in their answers. –  kiamlaluno Feb 20 '13 at 16:02
    
@kiamlaluno Ok then. Thanks. –  bytebuster Feb 20 '13 at 16:10
    
Is this question about having such CW question on the main site, or the meta site? –  kiamlaluno Feb 23 '13 at 13:28

2 Answers 2

Here's how I see it organized (voting is separate to the general idea, so I guess the score here will be lower than for the question ;)). Each section will eventually grow into a separate answer to a Comm.Wiki question.

In fact, check the respective Comm.Wiki for Chinese.SE to see how it looks after some effort.

  • Books

    • ...
  • Dictionaries Online

    • OneLook dictionary search — search through N major dictionaries online;
    • ...
  • Tests and Assessments

    • CEFR — where it is accepted, cost, availability, certified test centers, ...
    • IELTS
    • TOEFL
    • ...
  • Language-Specific sites

    • For native Chinese speakers
      • Web Site 1 — contains free podcasts. Requires average level of comprehension;
      • Web Site 2 — first NN lessons are free; monthly subscription costs $X. Does not require an entry level;
      • ...
    • For native Italian speakers
      • ...
    • For native Russian speakers
      • ...
  • Other Resources

    • Googling for a definition of a certain word: type define crocodile tears in a Google search field to find its definition;
    • Omegle — a chat with native speakers;
    • Chat Roulette — a chat with native speakers;
    • Lang-8 is a proofreading website where you can write a journal post in English, and have your entry corrected by native speakers of English. In return, you're encouraged to correct journal posts written in the language that you're a native speaker of.
  • Didactic and Learning to Learn

share
    
Excellent. A similar CW is on Meta ELU, but not regularly maintained. –  StoneyB Feb 19 '13 at 18:52
    
@StoneyB IMO, the Chinese one looks better elaborated. :) Anyway, we will copy everything relevant. –  bytebuster Feb 19 '13 at 19:01
1  
The Russian site also has one, but it appears to be very similar to the Chinese one. –  ctype.h Feb 20 '13 at 3:43
1  
We have a CW like this on Japanese Language & Usage. We refer to it fairly often! It's been useful. –  snailplane Feb 20 '13 at 11:26
    
I'm not sure about Omegle and Chat Roulette. I tried using it once (followed the links here) and almost all the connections I got, the first question was ASL! –  Damkerng T. Jan 1 at 19:18

Yet another thought, maybe worth a separate voting.

Provided that CW will exist, suggesting to endorse a policy of closing questions related to learning resources as dupes of the FAQ Comm.Wiki.

If a question is about resources, but not covered by Comm.Wiki, we wait for nice answers (and let people harvest some reputation) and then copy a good content to the Comm.Wiki and close an original question.

Please downvote this answer if you think that other questions should not be closed.

share
2  
I do not think such questions should be closed, but I think any useful resources from the answers and comments should be added to the CW list. –  ctype.h Feb 20 '13 at 3:29
2  
The problem: who will do the copying? –  StoneyB Feb 20 '13 at 12:42
    
@StoneyB That's the issue. If we agree that individual Q's should be closed in favor of CW, it's easy to define that close-voters copy first, and vote then. OTOH, it is not very fair to askers (at the moment they asked, it was not yet a dupe). –  bytebuster Feb 20 '13 at 12:46
3  
Sometimes an excellent answer, far better than the others, comes along several months or a year or two after the question was asked. Closing the questions would prevent such answers. –  ctype.h Feb 20 '13 at 15:04

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .